Rule 10b5-1 plans, explained: why some insider trades tell you nothing
A 10b5-1 plan lets an executive trade on a pre-set schedule. Here's how the rule works, what the 2023 SEC amendments changed, and how to read plan trades on Form 4.
· 8 min read · By Insider Option
A Rule 10b5-1 plan is a pre-arranged trading schedule that lets a corporate insider buy or sell their company's stock without being accused of trading on inside information. If you look at insider filings for long, you will notice that a large share of executive sales are made under one. Knowing how these plans work is the single most useful filter for separating meaningful insider activity from noise.
What the rule actually says
SEC Rule 10b5-1, adopted in 2000, defines when a trade is made "on the basis of" material non-public information. It also creates an affirmative defence: if an insider adopts a written plan while they are not aware of material non-public information, and the plan fixes the amount, price and timing of later trades (or hands that discretion to someone else), trades executed under the plan are protected even if the insider later learns something.
The logic is simple. Executives are paid largely in stock and need some way to sell it. A plan set up in advance, during a "clean" window, removes the insider's ability to time individual trades — which is exactly why plan trades say so little about what the insider currently thinks.
What changed in 2023
The defence was widely criticised for being easy to game: insiders could adopt a plan and trade almost immediately, run several overlapping plans and cancel the inconvenient ones, or set up single-trade plans just before news. The SEC adopted amendments in December 2022, effective February 2023, that closed most of these gaps:
- Cooling-off periods. Directors and officers must wait the later of 90 days after adoption or two business days after the company discloses results for the quarter in which the plan was adopted (capped at 120 days) before the first trade. Other insiders wait 30 days.
- Certification. Directors and officers must certify, when adopting a plan, that they are not aware of material non-public information and are adopting it in good faith.
- No overlapping plans, with narrow exceptions, and only one single-trade plan per 12 months.
- A good-faith requirement that runs for the whole life of the plan, not just at adoption.
- Disclosure. Companies must report each quarter which directors and officers adopted or terminated a plan, and Forms 4 and 5 gained a checkbox flagging transactions made under a 10b5-1 plan.
How to read a 10b5-1 trade on Form 4
On a Form 4 filing, look for two things. First, the 10b5-1 checkbox, which since April 2023 states directly that the transaction was made under a plan. Second, the footnotes: filers often state the plan's adoption date, which tells you how far in advance the trade was fixed.
Combine that with the transaction code. A code S (open-market sale) under a plan is the most routine event in insider data. A code P (open-market purchase) outside any plan is the rarest and, according to decades of research, the most informative.
Do plan trades still carry information?
Less than discretionary trades, but not zero. Academic work before the 2023 amendments — notably Jagolinzer (2009) — found that trades under 10b5-1 plans could still outperform, consistent with insiders timing when they adopted or cancelled plans. The amendments were designed to shrink exactly that edge, and there is not yet a long post-2023 record to say how far they succeeded.
Two patterns remain worth watching:
- Plan terminations. An executive cancelling a sales plan can mean they no longer want to sell at current prices. Terminations now appear in quarterly reports.
- Sales that are not under a plan. A discretionary sale by a senior officer, especially when several insiders sell at once, is more notable precisely because most selling is pre-scheduled. Our piece on insider selling versus buying covers the cases that matter.
What this means in practice
If you screen insider activity, exclude plan trades by default and look at them separately. That one filter removes a large share of the selling that makes insider feeds look alarming, and leaves the discretionary decisions that the research on insider buying is actually about. The insider trading tracker on Insider Option lets you filter Form 4 transactions by transaction code and plan status for this reason.
This article is for information only and is not investment, legal or tax advice. Rules summarised here are simplified; consult the SEC's adopting release for the full requirements.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a Rule 10b5-1 plan?
- A 10b5-1 plan is a written plan an insider adopts while not in possession of material non-public information, setting in advance the amount, price and dates of future trades. Trades executed under a valid plan give the insider an affirmative defence against insider-trading liability under SEC Rule 10b5-1.
- What is the cooling-off period for a 10b5-1 plan?
- Since the SEC's 2023 amendments, directors and officers must wait the later of 90 days after adopting a plan or two business days after the company reports results for that quarter, capped at 120 days, before the first trade. Other insiders who are not the company itself wait 30 days.
- How can I tell if an insider trade was made under a 10b5-1 plan?
- Since April 2023, Form 4 and Form 5 include a checkbox indicating that a reported transaction was made under a plan intended to satisfy Rule 10b5-1. Companies must also disclose quarterly when their directors and officers adopt or terminate such plans.
- Are 10b5-1 plan sales a bearish signal?
- Usually not on their own. Plan sales are scheduled months in advance, often to diversify or cover taxes, so they carry little information about the insider's current view. Discretionary open-market purchases outside a plan are the stronger signal in academic research.
Keep reading
- SEC Form 4, explained: how to read an insider trading filing — Form 4 is how corporate insiders disclose their trades within two business days. Here's what every box and transaction code means, and how to tell a meaningful buy from routine compensation.
- Insider selling vs insider buying: why one signal is real and the other mostly isn't — Insiders buy for one reason and sell for a dozen. Here's why insider purchases carry information, why most insider selling is noise, and how to spot the sales that do matter.
- Do corporate insider buys predict stock returns? What the research says — When a CEO buys their own company's stock on the open market, is that a signal worth trading on? Decades of academic research say yes — with important caveats. Here's the evidence.